swirt
Forum founder. Former Owner.
- Joined
- May 17, 2008
- Messages
- 3,210
- Reaction score
- 1
Faced with concerns of disturbing guests as I mow around their cabins (both for noise and kicking up dust) combined with rising gas prices I bought a reel mower. I had one as a kid and it was a big heavy monster.
I bought the Scotts Classic (20" cutting path) and I have to say I am mostly very happy with it. It is light and easy to push (siginficantly easier than my self propelled mulching mower) and as I had hoped, it doesn't make much noise and raises no dust. The mowable part of my yard is roughly half an acre and it takes me only 5 or 10 minutes more than when using my self-propelled mower. Up hills, down hills.. no problem. One other thing I like about it is that you can mow at the edge of a mulched area (like the edge of a flower garden) and it won't suck up all the mulch and spray it all over the yard.
The one drawback it has is that it can't cut anything that is taller than half its height. Anything taller than 5 or 6 inches just gets pushed flat before it gets to the cutter. So grass gets cut just fine and many weeds get cut without a problem. Its the dandelion flowers and stems that don't get cut (the dandelion leaves get cut). So for me in the early part of spring when the dandelions are in full force, it is a problem.
Overall though so far so good, I like it, it makes me feel Greener just pusing it
I'm still keeping my mulching mower for heavy dandelion season, for mulching leaves in the fall, and for when I have gone a way for too long on vacation and the yard is severely overgrown.
Pros: comes close to paying for itself in one season, quiet, clean, no dust, no fumes, cuts grass easily lightweight (~30 lbs)
Cons: doesn't do well with dandelion stalks or super tall grass, won't chop up leaves in the fall, won't bust up small sticks the way my mulching mower does.

The one drawback it has is that it can't cut anything that is taller than half its height. Anything taller than 5 or 6 inches just gets pushed flat before it gets to the cutter. So grass gets cut just fine and many weeds get cut without a problem. Its the dandelion flowers and stems that don't get cut (the dandelion leaves get cut). So for me in the early part of spring when the dandelions are in full force, it is a problem.
Overall though so far so good, I like it, it makes me feel Greener just pusing it
Pros: comes close to paying for itself in one season, quiet, clean, no dust, no fumes, cuts grass easily lightweight (~30 lbs)
Cons: doesn't do well with dandelion stalks or super tall grass, won't chop up leaves in the fall, won't bust up small sticks the way my mulching mower does.