For us we can usually hold out for a two night weekend stay in October or certain peak or holiday weekends when we know there will be many people in the area, the rest of the year when demand is lower I'm afraid it would hurt the pocketbook, sure is nice though when everyone stays two nights..
I hold the line on two nighters for as long as possible in season. This is a big wedding town but most guests just want Saturday night.
We have one weekend in December that I require a 2 night stay. Right now I have only 2 rooms left for this coming December for that weekend. I don't back down on that one until Friday!
We found out the hard way that not sticking to minimums left us we lots of open rooms when later callers wanted 3 nights and we'd booked all of Saturday for one nighters.
A good chunk of the country doesn't really acknowledge Columbus day so they don't get it's a real holiday here with many people getting a 3 day weekend. No, you can't book 3 rooms for a 1 night stay! It's also Canada's Thanksgiving and parent's visiting at the college.
.