We only keep brochures & menus for places that we have actually visited, things we've actually done, friends that have businesses that we know & respect (even if we don't use the service, but can honestly recommend in good faith). We get businesses and realtors coming by all the time wanting to drop off brochures, business cards, fliers and other crap. We certainly don't want to overwhelm our guests and like being able to say that the places are Innkeeper tested & approved.
A friend of the owner built three small wood brochure holders - two slots deep, four & five brochures long - that sit on a long table in the entrance hallway. Then misc other holders & non-holdered stuff laying on it. I often go through it and cull the herd... if there's too much crap no one wants to even stop to look at it. We have all menus to the right, shopping in the middle & activities on the left. The map in the middle is of our shopping district. I keep it open to encourage people to pick them up. Our biz assoc puts that together (I'm on the board so I peddle them heavily!)
.