PAII CEO Resigns, PAII Board of Directors have been removed

Bed & Breakfast / Short Term Rental Host Forum

Help Support Bed & Breakfast / Short Term Rental Host Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Breakfast Diva

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2009
Messages
5,911
Reaction score
29
Jay K. has just given his notice. The PAII board has been removed. No one seems to know the whole story and the board of it's parent company DIA has not released any notice. Here is Jay's letter to the membership this afternoon:
Every year at this time I remember my days in high school, in Latin class specifically, when I learned about the Roman god, Janus. Janus was a deity with two faces and represented new beginnings, as well as passages, doors, transitions, etc. One bearded face is looking to the past, while the other looks to the future. The Romans named the month of January in honor of this god. It seems both coincidental and appropriate that as January begins, I share with the association and industry that I recently tendered my resignation to the PAII board of directors. In my farewell column, I will look both at the past and to the future.
Believe it or not, my first-ever interaction with PAII was around 2002, well before I was hired. When PAII was still in Santa Barbara, California, and they were looking for a new CEO at that time, this young buck (I was 28 at the time) sent my resume to some lady named Jo Ann Bell. I didn't even get a phone interview. :) Fast forward to the spring of 2007, and the job opening showed up on my radar screen once again. This time, I think the decision-makers at PAII saw something in this 33 year old kid.
The PAII conference was in Myrtle Beach that same month, just 90 miles up the road from Charleston. I had cleared a fantastic and fun phone interview with board member, AnneMarie DeFreest, and asked if I could get a badge and come to the show "incognito." I wanted to check things out, and what a great opportunity at which to get a feel for the culture of PAII - their annual conference. I walked into the convention center, got my badge from a curious and whispering PAII staff, and ventured into the men's restroom. Upon entry into the restroom, I was greeted by some incredibly friendly innkeepers, asking who I was, where was I from, what inn did I have, etc. I thought to myself, "Well, isn't THIS a friendly group of people." I sat in the audience of a few classes and the "State of the Industry" panel discussion, which included as I recall Eric Goldreyer, Phyllis Murray, Deb Mosimann and a few others. I started thinking, "OK...these people know what they're talking about. They have some visible passion." I was beginning to really like this group.
Then I had my two formal interviews with the full board at both the Hamanassett Bed and Breakfast and the Haddonfield Inn. This is when I fell in love with PAII. The passion, enthusiasm and dedication of this group of volunteers - and simply their fantastic personalities - sealed the deal for me. So much so that I dragged my Southern-bred wife and 18-month old daughter out of Charleston, South Carolina, to South Jersey. The board-CEO relationship is critical to the success of an organization, and I knew that we would strike the right balance and work together incredibly well.
There is no question that PAII was facing many challenges at that time. Despite the work of some very good people I admire, the trajectory had been moving downward for several years. I was honestly relishing the opportunity to reverse the trends, repair relationships and elevate the association and the industry's standing in multiple ways. When I was a kid, I took a personality test that said my personality type was a "gardener," and I couldn't wait to start tilling the soil and planting some seeds at PAII.
Here is a little list of the highlights:
Reversed the shrinking membership and brought new innkeepers into PAII, as well as brought back scores of long-gone members
Launched and maintained a well-loved magazine, Innkeeping Now (keeping print alive isn't easy in this day and age!)
Hosted and improved our industry's best conferences, including the Innkeeping Conference & Trade Show, as well as regional conferences
Launched the industry's first-ever, grassroots campaign to kill stereotypes and convince travelers to give B&Bs a shot - the Better Way to Stay campaign
Improved the portfolio of member programs and services, including quadrupling the volume of educational offerings to innkeepers
Rebuilt and built positive relationships with all of the allied associations in our industry, including the scores of provincial, state and local B&B associations and Select Registry
Served and elevated the B&B industry in leadership capacities at the US Travel Association, Advocates for Independent Business and other impactful organizations
Successfully represented the B&B industry's interests with some big-hitters like TripAdvisor, Yelp and various legislative and public policy officials
Cultivated positive press for our industry in publications like the Wall Street Journal, USA Today and dozens of other trade and mainstream news outlets
Engaged sponsors and vendors in new ways that made them truly a part of the PAII family, including the launch of the Key Supporter recognition program
Overall, strengthened the financial positioning of PAII by improving the top and bottom lines and diversifying our revenue streams
Over the past six and a half years, and during one of the most difficult economic times we have seen in our lifetime, we were able to accomplish some wonderful things. And when I say "we," I truly mean that running PAII is a team endeavor. We've had dozens and dozens of dedicated volunteers help in so many ways - from introducing speakers at conference...to teaching their peers at the same events...and giving feedback and input on our Advisory Council and Committee of 100...to dedicating hundreds and hundreds of hours of service in critical leadership posts on our board of directors. And the PAII staff ALWAYS gave more than we paid for. Their commitment and desire to serve our members and industry always humbled me.
I want you all to know that my resignation comes not as a result of some seven-year-itch or desire to go on to bigger and better things. I love this industry. Love the people. But there have been changes in circles higher than my seat, and I had a vision for PAII that wasn't necessarily congruent with their vision. We have agreed to disagree about many decisions made here at PAII, and I tendered my resignation on December 30th, giving a required three months of notice with my final day of employment to be March 30, 2014 with the offer to continue my hard work as President and CEO until that time.
I wish my exit was under different circumstances, but I offer nothing but my sincerest best wishes to all the members of PAII - the aspiring innkeepers, vendors, interim innkeepers and innkeepers - and all other good people within the B&B industry. I'll close by sharing a fortune I received recently in one of those classic Chinese cookies: "We can't control the wind, but we can always adjust the sails." If you wish to reach me, feel free to email me at [email protected].
Warmest regards,
Jay
 
...there have been changes in circles higher than my seat, and I had a vision for PAII that wasn't necessarily congruent with their vision...I wish my exit was under different circumstances
Maybe he was fired by the doily lobby. Or maybe TA bought PAII and fired the whole board and exec. director to shut up the whining us small-timers.
Quite a surprise. Jay is a great guy, bright and dedicated. He was probably a lot more popular with the membership than those in "circles higher than his seat."
But what do I know. I left when they more than tripled my membership fee. No regrets, but it would have been fun to read the PAII forum over the next week.
 
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
I am not super surprised, I wish Jay all the best in an arena where he can do even greater things!
 
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
I am not super surprised, I wish Jay all the best in an arena where he can do even greater things!.
Joey Bloggs said:
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
Good point. It could be taken either way, and perhaps they would silence the chat board until the dust settles. But if it's all owned by DIA (or is it DIVA?) then I guess they, who every they are, could replace the board of directors.
 
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
I am not super surprised, I wish Jay all the best in an arena where he can do even greater things!.
Joey Bloggs said:
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
Yeah I guess Diva means the chat board. When I go the the PAII site I don't even see a place to log in. If you click "My Account" it just reloads the homepage. If you click Resources at the bottom of the page it also reloads the homepage.
I'll bet a lot of folks are mad about being silenced this way. Of course, there's always Innspiring!
 
Everyone will be here on Innspiring soon...they have to.
WELCOME TO THE DARK OTHER SIDE INNMATES! :) Come on in, the water's fine...
 
From the PAII forum
Unbeknownst to most people in the industry, PAII is owned by Distinguished Inns Alliance (DIA) and is a for-profit company. There were a number of stockholders who were involved in the ownership of PAII going back 13 years when the company was purchased from Pat Hardy and JoAnn Bell. Ralph and I were stockholders in DIA and donated our shares to PAII, along with a number of other stockholders, when there was serious interest in taking PAII non-profit.
DIA as the ownership entity for PAII has the right to appoint the board of PAII. The current PAII Board consists of 4 DIA stockholders. They have named Pete Holladay as President and CEO of PAII.
So ... the volunteer board is out, the stockholders who think PAII can be run as a for-profit organization are in. Guess I made a mistake by sending in my dues last month.
 
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
I am not super surprised, I wish Jay all the best in an arena where he can do even greater things!.
Joey Bloggs said:
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
Good point. It could be taken either way, and perhaps they would silence the chat board until the dust settles. But if it's all owned by DIA (or is it DIVA?) then I guess they, who every they are, could replace the board of directors.
.
PAII Board of Directors!
 
Thanks for the info Innkeep! I knew they were owned by a company rather than being a real professional association like the American Medical Association or the Bar Association. That always seemed strange to me.
What a mess!
Wonder if someone should start a new forum topic like "PAII Management Shakeup" or something so visitors will more easily find the discussion.
 
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
I am not super surprised, I wish Jay all the best in an arena where he can do even greater things!.
Joey Bloggs said:
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
Yeah I guess Diva means the chat board. When I go the the PAII site I don't even see a place to log in. If you click "My Account" it just reloads the homepage. If you click Resources at the bottom of the page it also reloads the homepage.
I'll bet a lot of folks are mad about being silenced this way. Of course, there's always Innspiring!
.
You're right Arkie, the form link is not where it used to be on the website! I didn't poke around to find it, but I went to an old e-mail that had a link for it, so I got into the forum.
PAII's whole Board of Directors have been removed.
 
Thanks for the info Innkeep! I knew they were owned by a company rather than being a real professional association like the American Medical Association or the Bar Association. That always seemed strange to me.
What a mess!
Wonder if someone should start a new forum topic like "PAII Management Shakeup" or something so visitors will more easily find the discussion..
I just changed the title.
 
Thanks for the info Innkeep! I knew they were owned by a company rather than being a real professional association like the American Medical Association or the Bar Association. That always seemed strange to me.
What a mess!
Wonder if someone should start a new forum topic like "PAII Management Shakeup" or something so visitors will more easily find the discussion..
I just changed the title.
.
Breakfast Diva said:
I just changed the title.
Good job!
 
Thank you for posting this. I emailed Jay to thank him for all he has done.
 
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
I am not super surprised, I wish Jay all the best in an arena where he can do even greater things!.
Joey Bloggs said:
When you say "The PAII board has been removed" you mean online board/forum, not whole board directors, right?
Good point. It could be taken either way, and perhaps they would silence the chat board until the dust settles. But if it's all owned by DIA (or is it DIVA?) then I guess they, who every they are, could replace the board of directors.
.
Thanks for the innfo innkeep. A Virginian is in the story again.
 
Thank you for posting this. I emailed Jay to thank him for all he has done..
Madeleine said:
Thank you for posting this. I emailed Jay to thank him for all he has done.
Jay is a remarkable young man who came from a non-innkeeping background, but who learned very quickly how to be an advocate for B&B's. The folks on the PAII forum don't think he has another job to go to. It'd be nice to overload his email mailbox.
 
Jay has given a 90 day notice and has not accepted another position at this time. My sincerest hope is that whatever restructuring is happening, that there is still a small chance of them straightening the crap out and Jay stays. It's probably just wishful thinking
cry_smile.gif
 
If they are "for profit" I wonder where the main profit comes from.
Vendors paying for space at shows? That probably just pays show expenses.
Membership dues? Again, not all that much. Pays for the headquarters office, staff, website, etc., but probably not much profit.
Ads in the magazine probably just pay to print and mail the magazine.
Overall seems better to have been a non-profit. But I don't know much about it. I should probably just shut up!
But I'm thinking back now, of all the innkeepers who said they would gladly pay the higher dues for the good of the organization. Wonder if they realized it was for the good of the owners, not the members.
 
Not much of a website, but here it is: http://distinguishedinnsalliance.com/
 
Back
Top